我國民事訴訟法官心證制度的確立和完善.pdf

1、復旦大學碩士學位論文我國民事訴訟法官心證制度的確立和完善姓名：朱泳武申請學位級別：碩士專業(yè)：法律指導教師：章武生20040326ABSTRACTFora10ngtime，withtheinfluenceofideologyandtraditionjudicialtheory，ChinadeniedthewesterntheoryoffreeproofthoroughlyEspeciallyincivil1itigation，thepri

2、ncipleofseekingtruthfromfactsiscarriedoutinevidencesystem1ikeincriminallitjgation。andjudgesareprohibitedfromusingfreeproofButwiththereformofjudicjalsystem，theindependentjudicialpowerisenlargedThereforethediscordantphenom

3、enon，suchasdiscretionalevaluatingtoofreelY，lackofprofessionalqualityandetc，comeintobeingAsaresult，itiSnecessarytostipulateasetofdiscretionalevaluationofevidencewithbothfreeproofandstrictrestrictionmechanism，byusingtheexp

4、erienceofthefreeproofsysteminwesterncountryandcombiningwiththejudicialtraditionofChinaaswellastherealconditionofourudges’personnelThedissettationisdemonstratedbvthefollowingparts：1Outlineoffreeproof：Thispartanalyzesthehi

5、storicaldevelopmentofevidencesystemfromdeity—impartevidencesystemtolegalevidencesystem，thentofreeproofevidencesystemEmergenceoffreeproofistheresultofSOCialdevelopmentaswellasthehistoricnecessitvofhumanbeingsfromUBCiviliz

6、edteasonInfact，theprocessoftrialistheprocessthroughwhichajudge’sinnerCOnYictionoftherealfactsofthecaseformsaccordingtotheevidenceprovidedbythepartiesItissocalled“Judge’sFreeProofProcess”ItisakindofobjectiveruleAfterover2

7、00yearsdevelopment，thefreeproofsystembecomesamorescientificevidencesystem2Unadmittedfreeproofunderthetheprincipleofseekingtruthfromfacts：Thispartanalyzestheprincipleofseekingtruthfromfacts，whichdominatedinourevidencesyst

8、emfora10ngtimeThesubstanceofthisevidencesystemisstillfreeproofHowever，onaccountoftheideologicalfactors，itusedtobedeniedandneglected，whichattributestothelackofscientificsafeguardandrestricti011offreeproof，andtotherealizat

9、ionofthegoalofjusticeandefficiency3Freeproofsystemestablishedbyjudicialinterpretation：Thispartanalyzestherelativecontentsconcerning“SeveralRulesontheCivilProcedureEvidence”oftheSupremeCourtItdemonstratesthatthescientific