論法典與法官的關(guān)系——并及法典的未來.pdf

1、山東大學碩士學位論文論法典與法官的關(guān)系——并及法典的未來姓名：周赟申請學位級別：碩士專業(yè)：法理學指導教師：謝暉林明20040401山東大學碩：匕學位論空ABSTRACTOnthepointofjurisprudence，therehavebeentwotypicalviewsabouttherelationbetweenjudgeandcode(here，theword‘code”hasthesamemeaningasstatutela

2、叼：onethinksthel蜮gecallnotapplythelawinacreativewayThatis，judgeisonlyallautomaticmachineofsellinglawHoweveLthestudyoflawsociologythehermenenticoflawthepsychologyandphilologyhasshowedthatthejudgeshouldnotevencouldnotbeonly

3、amachine。Ontheotherhand，sometheorists，suchasFrank，protestedthatthejudgeisthetruelawmakerincapeObviouslythepoint，liketheviewpointabovementioned，isallextremeone，tOOAndithassomeaspectsofselfcontradictionTheauthorthinksthere

4、lationbetweencodeandjudgeshouldbeameanone，neword“mean’’wasfirstusedastheHellenicphrasetomersonbyArisiotle，whichisthemaincharacterofvirtueIn0therwordsmeauthorthinkstherelationshouldbebasedonthefollowing：thecodecontrolsthe

5、judgetocertainextentandthejudgeCanappealtohigcreativityincourt，tooThen，howtokeeptherelationalwaysdevelopinginthismeallwayTheauthorproteststhatthekeytOthisquestionincludestwosides：oneis棲institutetheprincipledcode。whichmea